76 Highlights 51 Differences 10 Reactions 0 Likes

Lull Original vs Amerisleep AS1: 76 Highlights & 51 Differences — So, Which Mattress Actually Works Better

Comparing two popular mattresses for firmness and comfort to help you sleep better. Here’s what sets Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 apart. From flippable design, anti-microbial treatment, head & foot elevation support & formaldehyde free to user comfort, this is your shortcut to choosing the right mattress.

74 Points
Lull Original
23 Points
Amerisleep
Amerisleep
Amerisleep AS1
Amerisleep AS1
vs

Highlights 217

No extras. Just what matters.
74 Points
vs
23 Points

Why is Lull Original better than Amerisleep AS1 ?

Scroll down for more facts

Foam Mattress Face-Off: Lull Original Versus Amerisleep AS1

When evaluating foam mattresses made in the USA and designed for home use worldwide, the Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 emerge as contenders with shared traits and distinctive qualities. Both models are medium profile, measuring 10 inches in thickness, offering foam-based comfort designed especially for back and stomach sleepers. Strong warranties and trial periods back each mattress; though the Lull Original's lifetime warranty and year-long 365-day trial contrast with Amerisleep AS1's 20-year warranty and shorter 100-day trial. While both provide gel or foam-based cooling technologies, their approach to comfort layers, firmness, and features differentiates them uniquely across performance, durability, and sustainability aspects.

Exploring the Lull Original: Comfort with Lasting Assurance

The Lull Original mattress, launched in 2015, capitalizes on a medium firmness level rated 7.5 out of 10, leaning towards balanced comfort suitable for a variety of sleepers. Its 3-inch gel-infused foam comfort layer offers enhanced cooling and faster responsiveness, demonstrated by a memory foam recovery time of just 0.3 seconds. The mattress layers combine memory foam with polyurethane foam for a supportive yet pressure-relieving experience.

One of Lull's standout features is its excellent edge support rating of 9.2/10, ideal for those who value seating comfort or sleeping near the mattress edges. Though it lacks hypoallergenic treatments and reinforced edges, its orthopedic certification adds credibility to its ergonomic design. Furthermore, the Lull accommodates split mattress options, allowing customization for couples, and its extensive lifetime warranty and 365-day trial period provide customers with risk-free long-term assurance.

Amerisleep AS1: A Sturdy and Allergy-Conscious Choice

Introduced recently in 2025, the Amerisleep AS1 elevates firmness slightly, with an 8 out of 10 firmness, reinforced by a 2-inch layer of Bio-Pur foam known for superior pressure relief and motion isolation. This mattress is designed to handle heavier sleepers as well, supporting a maximum weight of 400 lbs and featuring high-density foam edges for solid perimeter support. The hypoallergenic treatment and anti-dust mite features, along with Asthma & Allergy Foundation Certification (AAFA), make the AS1 especially appealing for allergy sufferers and pet owners. 

Its temperature control uses a combination of Bio-Pur foam with airflow channels and moisture-wicking fabric, designed to keep sleepers comfortable across climates. Added conveniences include compatibility with adjustable bases, split king sizes, and portability enhancements like easy transport handles and a storage bag. Moreover, Amerisleep's indentation resistance guarantee and superior sag resistance signal durability advantages, complemented by its 20-year warranty.

Quick Take

The Lull Original shines through with its generous 365-day trial and lifetime warranty, offering medium firmness comfort infused with cooling gel and remarkable edge support. Meanwhile, Amerisleep AS1 brings firmer resilience with enhanced pressure relief, allergy-friendly treatments, and eco-conscious construction, alongside portability perks and adaptable sleeping options.

Bottom Line

For those seeking a budget-friendly mattress with a longer risk-free trial and superior edge seating support, the $349 Lull Original is an inviting choice. Conversely, sleepers prioritizing firmer support, allergy protection, advanced temperature regulation, and sustainability might find the $849 Amerisleep AS1 a worthwhile investment despite the higher price. Both mattresses offer excellent foam comfort, but your preference for warranty length, firmness, and special features can guide your decision.

Verdict

  • Winner: Amerisleep AS1 - Combines firmer support, allergy-friendly tech, and eco-conscious materials with advanced cooling and durability features.
  • Runner-up: Lull Original - Delivers medium firmness comfort, longer trial, and lifetime warranty at a friendly price, with superb edge support but fewer advanced features.

Comparisons 21

Two enter. One leaves your cart.

Price comparisons

(✱) Prices may be changed at any time without further notice.

Related comparisons 21

Because one duel is never enough.

Comparisons & Facts 217

Side by side. The numbers. The features. No drama.

Need better nights? Start with a better mattress. This side-by-side of Lull Original vs Amerisleep AS1 covers features, support, and what real sleepers say.

General Information 11

Warranty Period

What is the warranty period?

88 Lull Original 1 Votes Lifetime

60 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes 20 Years

Duration of warranty coverage.

The lifetime warranty with Lull Original really impresses me over Amerisleep AS1's limited 20 years which might matter for long-term peace of mind.

See more

Product Type

What type of mattress is it?

38 Lull Original 0 Votes Foam

40 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Foam

Lull Original
Lull Original

The Lull Original is an all-foam mattress, ideal for those who want a consistent and even sleep surface. It's designed for people who prefer minimal sinkage and a balanced feel with medium firmness. Great for those who sleep on their back or stomach.

Defines the fundamental mattress category.

Model Name

What is the model name?

62 Lull Original 0 Votes Original

74 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes AS1

Lull Original
Lull Original

The "Original" Lull mattress is the brand's first and most affordable foam option, offering a straightforward sleep experience with a slightly firmer feel. It’s a popular choice for budget-conscious buyers who want good value without sacrificing comfort.

Provides the marketing name used by the brand.

Release Year

What is the release year?

4 Lull Original 0 Votes 2015

86 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes 2025

Lull Original
Lull Original

Launched in 2015, the Lull Original has been a trusted option for sleepers looking for an affordable yet high-quality foam mattress. It has remained a popular choice due to its balance of price and comfort.

Indicates when the product was introduced to the market.

Intended Use

What is the intended use?

58 Lull Original 0 Votes Home

60 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Home

Lull Original
Lull Original

Designed for use at home, whether for a master bedroom or guest room. It provides solid, reliable support for back and stomach sleepers, making it a versatile choice for everyday use.

Defines the usage context.

Model Number

What is the model number?

Who knows? 0 Votes Lull Original (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Unique identifier used internally or for warranty claims.

Country of Manufacture

Where is the mattress manufactured?

83 Lull Original 0 Votes USA

85 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes USA

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Country of Manufacture

The Country of Manufacture for both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 is USA, ensuring domestic production for both brands.

Shows where the mattress is manufactured.

Target Market

What is the target market?

88 Lull Original 0 Votes Global

70 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes US, Global

Specifies the geographic or demographic market.

Mattress Type

What is the mattress type?

18 Lull Original 0 Votes Foam

20 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Foam

Categorizes construction type.

Trial Period Length

What is the trial period length?

365 Nights 0 Votes
Lull Original
100 Nights 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Indicates how many nights consumers can try the mattress risk-free.

Free Return Policy

Does it come with a free return policy?

Yes 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Free Return Policy

Both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 offer a Free Return Policy, providing customers with a risk-free trial experience.

Shows whether the product allows hassle-free returns.

Dimensions & Weight 110

Mattress Size

What is the mattress size?

90 Lull Original 0 Votes Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, Cal King, Split King

Lull Original
Lull Original

Available in multiple sizes, including Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King, the Lull Original fits most bed frames and is versatile for any room size, from small to spacious.

Amerisleep AS1
Amerisleep AS1

Available in a wide range of sizes. Whether you need a compact option for a child’s room or a spacious King for a master bedroom, there's a size to fit your needs.

Identifies the size for the mattress.

Width (Full)

What is the Full mattress width?

54 inch 0 Votes
Lull Original
54 inch 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Standard width for Full (Double) mattress.

Width (Queen)

What is the Queen mattress width?

60 inch 0 Votes
Lull Original
60 inch 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Standard width for Queen size mattress.

Depth (Twin XL)

What is the Twin XL mattress length?

80 inch 0 Votes
Lull Original
80 inch 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Standard length for Twin XL mattress.

Depth (King)

What is the King mattress length?

80 inch 0 Votes
Lull Original
80 inch 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Standard length for King size mattress.

Weight (Twin)

What is the Twin mattress weight?

50 lbs 0 Votes
Lull Original
45 lbs 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Standard weight range for a Twin size mattress.

Weight (Full)

What is the Full mattress weight?

63 lbs 0 Votes
Lull Original
63 lbs 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Standard weight range for a Full mattress.

Package Height (King)

What is the King package height?

Who knows? 0 Votes Lull Original (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Height of King mattress package when boxed.

Width (Twin)

What is the Twin mattress width?

38 inch 0 Votes
Lull Original
38 inch 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Standard width for Twin size mattress.

Width (Twin XL)

What is the Twin XL mattress width?

38 inch 0 Votes
Lull Original
38 inch 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Standard width for Twin XL mattress.

Width (King)

What is the King mattress width?

76 inch 0 Votes
Lull Original
76 inch 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Standard width for King size mattress.

Width (California King)

What is the Cal King mattress width?

72 inch 0 Votes
Lull Original
72 inch 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Standard width for California King mattress.

Comfort & Firmness 13

Firmness Level

What is the firmness level?

38 Lull Original 0 Votes Medium

30 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Firm

Lull Original
Lull Original

Medium firmness offers balanced support, making it ideal for back and stomach sleepers who prefer some cushioning without sinking in too much.

Amerisleep AS1
Amerisleep AS1

The AS1 is designed with firm support in mind (8/10 on the firmness scale). This makes it an excellent choice for back and stomach sleepers who need a solid, supportive surface to maintain spinal alignment.

Describes the general firmness category.

Pressure Relief Rating

What is the pressure relief rating?

13 Lull Original 0 Votes Fair

90 Amerisleep AS1 1 Votes Excellent

Lull Original
Lull Original

Rated as fair, the Lull Original provides moderate pressure relief, making it suitable for back and stomach sleepers. However, side sleepers may find it too firm for their hips and shoulders.

Rates how well the mattress relieves pressure points.

Amerisleep AS1 totally takes the cake with its excellent pressure relief compared to Lull Original's fair rating which really helps if you have aches and pains.

See more

Comfort Layer Thickness

What is the comfort layer thickness?

3 inch 0 Votes
Lull Original
2 inch 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Amerisleep AS1
Amerisleep AS1

The top comfort layer is 2 inches of Bio-Pur foam. While it provides some cushioning and relief from pressure points, the primary feel of the mattress remains firm, ideal for sleepers who want support with just a touch of softness.

Thickness of the comfort layer on top.

Temperature Regulation Feature

Does it have temperature regulation features?

Yes 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Temperature Regulation Feature

Both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 feature Temperature Regulation, enhancing sleeping comfort by managing heat retention.

Indicates if mattress is designed to maintain neutral sleep temperature.

Cooling Technology

What cooling technology is included?

88 Lull Original 0 Votes Gel-Infused Foam

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Bio-Pur Foam

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Cooling Technology

Lull Original uses Gel-Infused Foam for Cooling Technology, whereas Amerisleep AS1 uses Bio-Pur Foam, indicating different cooling approaches between the mattresses.

GDescribes specific cooling methods used.

Firmness Scale Rating

What is the firmness rating?

69 Lull Original 1 Votes 7.5/10

78 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes 8/10

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Firmness Scale Rating

Lull Original's Firmness Scale Rating is 7.5/10, while Amerisleep AS1's rating is not provided, implying firmness details are limited for Amerisleep.

Numeric scale where 1 is softest and 10 is firmest.

I find the 7.5 firmness on the Lull Original pretty comfy and well balanced while the Amerisleep AS1 is firmer at 8 making it better if you want that solid feel.

See more

Edge Support Rating

What is the edge support rating?

80 Lull Original 1 Votes 9.2/10

70 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes 8/10

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Edge Support Rating

Lull Original rates higher on Edge Support Rating with 9.2/10 compared to Amerisleep AS1's 8/10, which might offer better edge stability in Lull.

Indicates stability around the mattress edges.

Edge support on the Lull at 9.2 is way better for sitting or sleeping near the sides compared to Amerisleep's 8 which feels less supportive to me.

See more

Comfort Technology

What comfort technology is included?

68 Lull Original 0 Votes Gel-Infused Foam

61 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Bio-Pur Foam

Lull Original
Lull Original

Gel-infused foam provides added comfort and cooling, making the mattress more responsive and helping to dissipate heat during sleep.

Special comfort features used in the top layers.

Motion Isolation Rating

What is the motion isolation rating?

52 Lull Original 0 Votes 7.2/10

68 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes 8/10

Lull Original
Lull Original

With a motion isolation score of 7.2/10, the mattress does a decent job of minimizing movement, but it may not be the best for very light sleepers sensitive to movement.

Measures how well the mattress prevents motion transfer.

Sleep Position Suitability

What sleep positions is it suitable for?

13 Lull Original 0 Votes Back, Stomach

15 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Back, Stomach

Lull Original
Lull Original

Best for back and stomach sleepers, as the mattress provides solid support for these positions. Side sleepers may not find the pressure relief they need.

Shows which sleeping positions are best supported.

Adjustable Firmness Range

Does it have an adjustable firmness range?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Shows if firmness can be adjusted or customized.

Ergonomic Certification

Does it have ergonomic certifications?

90 Lull Original 0 Votes Orthopedic Approved

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Orthopedic Approved

Lists recognized ergonomic approvals.

Construction & Materials 16

Comfort Layer Material

What is the comfort layer material?

88 Lull Original 0 Votes Memory Foam

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Bio-Pur Foam

Materials used in the comfort layers.

Quilting Type

What quilting type is used?

80 Lull Original 0 Votes Tight Top

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Tight Top

Describes the quilting style on the mattress surface.

Coil Type

What type of coil is used?

Who knows? 0 Votes Lull Original (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Identifies the coil construction used.

Natural / Organic Material

Does it use natural or organic materials?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates whether natural or organic materials are included.

Eco-Friendly Material Certification

What eco-friendly certifications are included?

90 Lull Original 0 Votes CertiPUR-US

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes CertiPUR-US

Certifications for sustainable materials.

Removable / Washable Cover

Does it have a removable and washable cover?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Removable / Washable Cover

Both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 do not offer Removable or Washable Covers, which might impact ease of cleaning.

Indicates if the cover can be removed and washed.

Flame Retardant Material

What flame retardant is used?

80 Lull Original 0 Votes Polyester

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Plant Fiber

Amerisleep AS1
Amerisleep AS1

The AS1 uses environmentally-friendly plant-based fibers to ensure the mattress meets fire safety standards. This is a healthier, safer option compared to traditional flame retardants like fiberglass.

Material used to meet fire safety standards.

Reinforced Edge Material

What is the reinforced edge material?

75 Lull Original 0 Votes No

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes High-Density Foam

Amerisleep AS1
Amerisleep AS1

High-density foam around the edges ensures durability and prevents sagging over time. This reinforced edge gives you extra stability when sitting on the edge of the mattress or sleeping near the perimeter.

Material reinforcement along the edges.

Mattress Core Material

What is the core material?

85 Lull Original 0 Votes Foam

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Foam

Defines the main support structure.

Cover Material

What is the cover material?

85 Lull Original 0 Votes Polyester, Rayon

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Celiant Fabric

Materials used for the outer cover.

Foam Type

What foam type is included?

88 Lull Original 0 Votes Memory Foam, Polyurethane Foam

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Memory Foam

Specifies the type of foam used.

Coil Count

What is the coil count?

Who knows? 0 Votes Lull Original (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Who knows? 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1 (Help us out by suggesting one!)

Number of coils in the mattress.

Performance & Durability 11

Flippable Design

Can the mattress be flipped?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Flippable Design

Neither Lull Original nor Amerisleep AS1 supports Flippable Design, limiting options for mattress rotation and maintenance.

Shows whether the mattress can be flipped.

Anti-Microbial Treatment

Does it have antimicrobial treatment?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if materials are treated to resist microbes.

Memory Foam Recovery Time

What is the recovery time of the foam?

0.3 sec 1 Votes
Lull Original
4 sec 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Amerisleep AS1
Amerisleep AS1

The Bio-Pur foam in the AS1 recovers quickly (within 4 seconds) after pressure is removed. This means you won’t feel “stuck” when moving during the night, unlike traditional memory foam mattresses that can take much longer to regain their shape.

Time it takes memory foam to return to shape.

Lull Original recovers memory foam super fast at 0.3 seconds which feels responsive, whereas Amerisleep AS1 takes 4 seconds, so Lull might suit active sleepers better.

See more

Sag Resistance Rating

What is the sag resistance rating?

80 Lull Original 0 Votes Medium

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes High

Amerisleep AS1
Amerisleep AS1

Designed to resist sagging, the AS1 retains its shape and firmness even with extended use. This durability ensures consistent support for years, making it a reliable long-term investment.

Rates the mattress resistance to sagging.

Indentation Resistance Guarantee

Is there an indentation resistance guarantee?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 1 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Assurance that mattress won’t indent prematurely.

Amerisleep AS1 providing an indentation resistance guarantee gives me more confidence on durability compared to Lull Original which doesn't offer this.

See more

Expected Lifespan

What is the expected lifespan?

10 Years 0 Votes
Lull Original
10 Years 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Average years the mattress is designed to last.

Density Rating

What is the density rating?

85 Lull Original 0 Votes Medium

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes High

Foam density that indicates durability and support.

Indentation Load Deflection (ILD)

What is the ILD value?

85 Lull Original 0 Votes Medium (20–30 lbs)

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Medium (20–30 lbs)

Measures foam firmness by required load to indent.

Rotatable Design

Can the mattress be rotated?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if mattress can be rotated to extend life.

Bed Bug Resistant

Is the mattress bed bug resistant?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Shows if the mattress has protection against bed bugs.

Warranty Coverage Type

What type of warranty coverage is provided?

90 Lull Original 0 Votes Full

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Full

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Warranty Coverage Type

Lull Original includes Full Warranty Coverage Type, ensuring comprehensive protection, whereas Amerisleep AS1's warranty coverage type is unspecified.

Describes the type of warranty coverage.

Comfort Adjustability 9

Head & Foot Elevation Support

Does it support head & foot elevation?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Head & Foot Elevation Support

Neither Lull Original nor Amerisleep AS1 supports Head & Foot Elevation, which might limit adjustability for users seeking elevation features.

Shows if mattress supports head and foot elevation.

Split Mattress Option

Is it available in split design?

Yes 1 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Split Mattress Option

Both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 include a Split Mattress Option, supporting customizable mattress configurations.

Shows if mattress can be split into two sides.

Both mattresses offer split mattress options, which is super convenient for couples wanting customized firmness on each side so can't really pick between them on that.

See more

Adjustable Base Compatibility

Is it compatible with adjustable bases?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if mattress can be used with an adjustable bed base.

Dual Firmness Option

Does it offer dual firmness?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if mattress offers two firmness levels in one design.

Removable Top Layer

Does it have a removable top layer?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if the top comfort layer can be removed or swapped.

Modular Layer Design

Does it have modular layers?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Modular Layer Design

The Modular Layer Design feature is not available in either Lull Original or Amerisleep AS1, meaning layers are likely fixed and unmodifiable.

Allows layers to be rearranged for customized comfort.

Customizable Firmness Inserts

Does it support firmness inserts?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Customizable Firmness Inserts

Both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 do not offer Customizable Firmness Inserts, indicating fixed firmness levels for these mattresses.

Supports inserts or pads to adjust firmness.

Smart Adjustable Firmness

Does it offer smart firmness adjustment?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if firmness can be changed via smart tech.

Replaceable Comfort Layer Program

Does it offer a replaceable comfort layer program?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if brand allows swapping comfort layers through a program.

Health & Safety 9

Allergy-Friendly

Is it allergy-friendly?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 1 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Allergy-Friendly

Lull Original is not described as Allergy-Friendly, but Amerisleep AS1 is, indicating Amerisleep AS1 may better support users with allergies.

Mattress is suitable for people with allergies.

Allergy-friendly features on Amerisleep AS1 are definitely great especially if you have sensitivities, while Lull lacks these treatments so AS1 wins here.

See more

Formaldehyde Free

Is the mattress formaldehyde free?

Yes 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if product is free from formaldehyde chemicals.

CertiPUR-US Certified

Is it CertiPUR-US certified?

Yes 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
CertiPUR-US Certified

Both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 are CertiPUR-US Certified, ensuring foam materials meet rigorous safety and performance standards.

Shows if foams meet CertiPUR-US safety standards.

GREENGUARD Gold Certified

Is it GREENGUARD Gold certified?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates compliance with low chemical emissions.

OEKO-TEX Certified

Is it OEKO-TEX certified?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Ensures textiles are free from harmful substances.

Chemical-Free Fire Barrier

Does it use a chemical-free fire barrier?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Fire safety protection without chemical sprays.

Low VOC Emission

Does it have low VOC emission?

Yes 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Ensures mattress has low volatile organic compound emissions.

Anti-Dust Mite Treatment

Does it have anti-dust mite treatment?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Treated to resist dust mites.

Asthma & Allergy Foundation Certification (AAFA)

Is it AAFA certified?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Asthma & Allergy Foundation Certification (AAFA)

Lull Original lacks Asthma & Allergy Foundation Certification (AAFA), while Amerisleep AS1 holds this certification, making Amerisleep more suitable for allergy sufferers.

Confirms endorsement by AAFA for allergy safety.

Temperature & Climate 8

Cooling Gel Infusion

Does it have cooling gel infusion?

Yes 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Cooling Gel Infusion

Lull Original features Cooling Gel Infusion, whereas Amerisleep AS1 does not, suggesting Lull may provide enhanced cooling through gel technology.

Indicates if cooling gel is infused in foam layers.

Phase Change Material

Does it use phase change materials?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Shows if mattress uses phase-change materials for temperature control.

Breathable Cover

Does it have a breathable cover?

Yes 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Breathable Cover

Both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 have a Breathable Cover, promoting airflow and improved sleeping comfort for both mattresses.

Indicates if the outer cover allows airflow.

Moisture-Wicking Fabric

Does it use moisture-wicking fabric?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Ensures cover or material draws away sweat and moisture.

Heat Dissipation Rating

What is the heat dissipation rating?

85 Lull Original 0 Votes Good

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Good

Rates how well mattress disperses heat.

Climate Adaptability

Is it climate adaptable?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Climate Adaptability

Amerisleep AS1 supports Climate Adaptability, while Lull Original does not, favoring Amerisleep for varying climate conditions.

Indicates if mattress adapts to various climates.

Seasonal Use Design

Does it have a seasonal use design?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Mattress is designed with seasonal dual sides for hot and cold weather.

Airflow Channel Design

Does it feature airflow channels?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Airflow Channel Design

Amerisleep AS1 features an Airflow Channel Design to enhance breathability, but Lull Original does not, which may affect temperature regulation.

Includes built-in airflow channels for ventilation.

Seating & Capacity 8

Couple Friendly Design

Is it couple friendly?

Yes 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if mattress minimizes motion transfer and supports two sleepers.

Child / Toddler Suitability

Is it suitable for children or toddlers?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Child / Toddler Suitability

Neither Lull Original nor Amerisleep AS1 is suitable for Child / Toddler use, indicating these mattresses target adult customers.

Shows if the mattress is safe for children or toddlers.

Seating Capacity

What is the seating capacity?

85 Lull Original 0 Votes 2 adults

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes 2 adults

Amerisleep AS1
Amerisleep AS1

With a maximum weight capacity of 400 lbs, the AS1 comfortably supports two adults. The mattress is sturdy enough for couples, with great edge support, ensuring no one feels unsupported near the edges.

Maximum number of people the mattress is designed to seat or sleep.

Maximum Weight Capacity

What is the maximum weight capacity?

500 lbs 0 Votes
Lull Original
400 lbs 0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Maximum Weight Capacity

Lull Original supports a Maximum Weight Capacity of 500 lbs, while Amerisleep AS1 supports 400 lbs, making Lull Original better for heavier individuals.

Maximum supported body weight.

Edge Sitting Comfort Rating

What is the edge sitting comfort rating?

90 Lull Original 0 Votes Excellent

0 Amerisleep AS1 0 Votes Good

Rates how comfortable and stable the edge feels when sitting.

Bunk Bed Compatibility

Is it compatible with bunk beds?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Bunk Bed Compatibility

Both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 lack Bunk Bed Compatibility, limiting their use in bunk bed setups.

Indicates if mattress is safe to use on bunk beds.

Pet Friendly Design

Is it pet friendly?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Pet Friendly Design

Lull Original does not have a Pet Friendly Design, whereas Amerisleep AS1 does, potentially making Amerisleep AS1 more suitable for pet owners.

Indicates if mattress surface resists pet scratches and fur.

Heavy Sleeper Support

Does it support heavy sleepers?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if the mattress provides extra support for heavier individuals.

Travel & Portability 7

Vacuum-Sealed Packaging

Does it use vacuum-sealed packaging?

Yes 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Describes whether mattress is vacuum sealed for delivery.

Easy Transport Handles

Does it have transport handles?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 1 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Easy Transport Handles

Amerisleep AS1 provides Easy Transport Handles, which Lull Original lacks, facilitating easier moving of the Amerisleep mattress.

Shows if mattress includes sewn-in handles for moving.

Amerisleep AS1 having easy transport handles is a big plus for me since it makes moving or setup way easier than the Lull Original without handles.

See more

Quick Expansion Time After Unboxing

What is the quick expansion time?

48 hrs 0 Votes
Lull Original
24 hrs 1 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Quick Expansion Time After Unboxing

Amerisleep AS1 has a Quick Expansion Time After Unboxing of 24 hours compared to Lull Original's 48 hours, meaning Amerisleep is ready for use faster.

Time needed for mattress to reach full shape after opening.

I like that Amerisleep AS1 expands quicker after unboxing in 24 hours, making it more convenient than Lull Original’s 48 hours wait.

See more

Roll Pack / Bed-in-Box Design

Is it a roll pack or bed-in-box design?

Yes 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Roll Pack / Bed-in-Box Design

Both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 come in a Roll Pack / Bed-in-Box Design, making shipping and setup more convenient.

Indicates if the mattress is compressed and rolled into a box for shipping.

Foldable Design

Is it foldable?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if mattress can be folded for storage or portability.

Storage Bag

Is a storage bag included?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Storage Bag

Lull Original does not include a Storage Bag, and Amerisleep AS1 also does not, so neither mattress offers this convenience.

Shows if mattress comes with a bag for storage or moving.

Re-Rollable for Storage/Move

Can it be re-rolled for storage or moving?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Re-Rollable for Storage/Move

Lull Original is not Re-Rollable for Storage or Move, but Amerisleep AS1 is, enhancing portability for Amerisleep.

Indicates if mattress can be re-rolled for easier moving or storage.

Technology & Smart Features 8

Sleep Tracking Integration

Does it integrate with sleep tracking?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if mattress integrates with sleep tracking systems.

Smart Sensor Connectivity

Does it connect with smart sensors?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Smart Sensor Connectivity

Both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1 do not have Smart Sensor Connectivity, thus lacking smart sleep tracking hardware integration.

Shows if mattress can connect with external smart sensors.

App Connectivity

Does it have app connectivity?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
App Connectivity

Neither Lull Original nor Amerisleep AS1 offers App Connectivity, so neither mattress supports mobile app integration.

Indicates if mattress has an app for customization or tracking.

USB Charging Port

Does it have USB charging ports?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Shows if mattress includes built-in USB charging ports.

Wireless Control

Does it have wireless control?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if features can be controlled wirelessly.

Smart Home Compatibility

Is it smart home compatible?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Smart Home Compatibility

Smart Home Compatibility is absent from both Lull Original and Amerisleep AS1, meaning no integration with smart home devices.

Shows if mattress works with Alexa, Google Home, etc.

Integrated Heating or Cooling Control

Does it have integrated heating or cooling?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Integrated Heating or Cooling Control

Neither Lull Original nor Amerisleep AS1 includes Integrated Heating or Cooling Control, so no active temperature adjustment features are available.

Indicates built-in heating or cooling control.

Anti-Snore Position Integration

Does it have anti-snore position integration?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Works with adjustable bases or sensors to reduce snoring.

Environmental & Sustainability 7

Recyclable Materials

Does it use recyclable materials?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Recyclable Materials

Amerisleep AS1 uses Recyclable Materials while Lull Original does not, indicating Amerisleep is more sustainable in material usage.

Indicates if mattress materials can be recycled.

Carbon Neutral Production

Is it carbon neutral in production?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Carbon Neutral Production

Amerisleep AS1 does not have Carbon Neutral Production, and Lull Original's status is not stated, indicating limited or unavailable information on environmental impact for both.

Indicates if manufacturer offsets or eliminates carbon emissions.

Sustainable Sourcing

Is it sustainably sourced?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Sustainable Sourcing

Amerisleep AS1 uses Sustainable Sourcing, whereas Lull Original does not, favoring Amerisleep for eco-friendly material sourcing.

Shows if materials come from responsibly managed sources.

Biodegradable Components

Does it include biodegradable components?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Biodegradable Components

Neither Lull Original nor Amerisleep AS1 includes Biodegradable Components, which may be a consideration for environmentally conscious buyers.

Shows if components naturally break down after disposal.

Renewable Energy Manufacturing

Is it manufactured with renewable energy?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

No 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Indicates if renewable energy is used in production.

Take-Back / Recycling Program

Does it have a take-back program?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Shows if brand offers a recycling or buy-back program.

Plastic-Free Packaging

Does it use plastic-free packaging?

No 0 Votes Lull Original

Yes 0 Votes Amerisleep AS1

Lull Original
vs
Amerisleep AS1
Plastic-Free Packaging

Amerisleep AS1 includes Plastic-Free Packaging while Lull Original does not, providing Amerisleep an advantage in reducing plastic waste.

Confirms if packaging avoids single-use plastics.

Surveys

Because hot takes deserve votes.

Comfort Level

How comfortable is this mattress for everyday use?

Super comfy — Feels like sleeping on a cloud
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Pretty comfortable — Good for most sleep positions
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Decent comfort — Works for short naps
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
A bit too firm — Not very cozy
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Hard and uncomfortable — Feels stiff all night
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Durability

How long does this mattress last before showing wear and tear?

Extremely durable — Over 12 years
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Long lasting — 9 to 12 years
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Good durability — 6 to 8 years
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Moderate lifespan — 3 to 5 years
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Very short lifespan — Less than 3 years
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Firmness

How firm does this mattress feel when lying down?

Extra firm — Very rigid and supportive
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Firm — Strong support with little sink
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Medium — Balanced support and softness
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Soft — Gently cushioned
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Ultra soft — Sinks in deeply
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Motion Isolation

How well does this mattress reduce movement transfer at night?

Excellent — Barely feel any motion
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Good — Only strong shifts are felt
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Decent — Minor movements are felt
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Somewhat poor — Frequent disturbance
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Very poor — Every movement is noticeable
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Thickness

How thick is this mattress in height?

Extra thick — Over 15 inches
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Thick — 13 to 15 inches
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Medium — 10 to 12 inches
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Thin — 6 to 9 inches
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Very thin — Less than 6 inches
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Temperature Regulation

How well does this mattress stay cool at night?

Very cool — Always stays fresh
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Cool — Feels comfortable most nights
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Average — Neutral temperature
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Somewhat warm — Gets a little stuffy
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Very hot — Traps a lot of heat
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Ease of Setup

How easy was it to set up this mattress at home?

Super simple — Done in no time
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Pretty easy — Quick setup without stress
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Manageable — Took some effort but fine
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
A bit difficult — Needed extra help
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
A total hassle — Took forever to set up
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Design Appeal

How attractive does this mattress look in a bedroom?

Beautiful design — Looks high-end
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Stylish — Adds to the room look
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Decent — Matches most rooms
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Okay — Nothing special
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Plain and boring — Looks cheap
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Pricing

How would you rate the price of this mattress?

Great value for money
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Pretty good price
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Fair deal
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Kinda pricey
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Crazy expensive
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Edge Support Strength

How sturdy are the edges of this mattress when sitting or lying near the side?

Excellent edge strength — No sinking at all
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Strong edge support — Slight compression only
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Moderate edge support — Noticeable sinking
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Weak edge support — Feels unstable at sides
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1
Very weak — Collapses when sitting on edge
0 Votes
Lull Original
0 Votes
Amerisleep AS1

Reviews 0

The good, the bad, and the brutally honest.

Average Rating

Lull
Lull
Lull Original
Lull Original
0 / 5 0 Reviews
Amerisleep
Amerisleep
Amerisleep AS1
Amerisleep AS1
0 / 5 0 Reviews

Discussions 0

Thoughts, takes, and hot debates.

Awards 0

Only the best made it here.

Collections 0

Treasures You’ve picked. No fluff, all fun.

More Mattresses 0

Unlock more awesome finds.

Other Lull Mattresses 3

Other Amerisleep Mattresses 8

Lull Original
Lull
Lull
Lull Original
Amerisleep AS1
Amerisleep
Amerisleep
Amerisleep AS1
vs